Effort vs Result
A candle attracts heavy activity but makes little net progress, firing when its close stays within 0.25× ATR of the preceding close.
At a glance#
- Direction
- Either way
- Fires
- At the candle's close
- Timeframes
- All nine, 1m to 1d
Follow it on Sinho#
How does it fire?#
- What it tells you
- Heavy participation has produced little net price change. The Signal is neutral; it does not choose an upward or downward outcome.
- When Sinho fires
- At the candle’s close, when its volume rank is high and its absolute change from the preceding close is small enough.
Anatomy#
Three parts, in the order they happen. The line joins candle closes.
- 1The past
The prior candles supply the volume comparison and ATR. The line here joins candle closes.
- 2Prior close
The immediately preceding candle’s close is the reference for the current price change.
- 3The close
Heavy volume ends with no more than 0.25× ATR of net change. Sinho fires here.
What Sinho checks#
The main rules, in plain words.
- Heavy participation
The candle trades on unusually heavy volume.
- Change between closes
Sinho measures the absolute difference between the current candle’s close and the immediately preceding candle’s close.
- Little net progress
Despite that activity, the close makes little progress from the preceding close.
- A neutral reading
The Signal remains neutral whether the small net change is upward, downward or zero. It records the mismatch between activity and progress.
- The close
Sinho fires when a candle closes with heavy volume but little net price progress.
Recent Effort vs Result Signals#
Every Effort vs Result Sinho fires, on every exchange and timeframe, is in the Feed as it happens.
Questions traders ask#
Does the candle itself have to be narrow?
No. Price can travel a wide high-to-low range and still finish near the preceding close. This rule limits net change, not the distance traveled within the candle.
Must it be a doji?
No. A doji compares a candle’s close with its own open. This type compares the close with the preceding candle’s close.
Does high activity prove who is absorbing the orders?
No. The measured facts are high volume and little net progress. The Signal does not identify particular buyers or sellers.
Can several consecutive candles qualify?
Yes. Each completed candle is evaluated against its own comparison history and preceding close. This type does not require a quiet reset between fires.
Does it create a new level?
No. It records this event without adding a new LevelBook level.
Key takeaways#
- 1
Effort vs Result compares high activity with little net change.
- 2
Volume ranks at least at the 90th percentile of the prior comparison history.
- 3
The close stays within 0.25× ATR of the preceding close, regardless of the candle’s full range.
- 4
The reading is neutral and creates no new LevelBook level.
Words on this page#
- Candle range
- The distance from a candle's low to its high, including both wicks.
- At the close
- Sinho checks the rule when the candle closes, and fires then.
- ATR
- Average true range: how far a bar usually travels, counting gaps between bars.
- Percentile rank
- The share of prior candles whose volume or full range is strictly smaller. Sinho compares the current candle with its past, excluding itself.
- Wilder ATR
- A smoothed average of true range. Sinho uses the prior candle’s value, before the candle being evaluated changes it.
