<!-- https://sinho.ai/university/signals/effort-vs-result · Sinho University -->

# Effort vs Result

A candle attracts heavy activity but makes little net progress, **firing when its close stays within 0.25× ATR of the preceding close**.

## At a glance

- **Direction**: Either way

- **Fires**: At the candle's close

- **Timeframes**: All nine, 1m to 1d

## Follow it on Sinho

- [See live Effort vs Result Signals](https://app.sinho.ai/feed/signals?do=feed&types=wyckoff%3Aeffort-vs-result)
- [Alert me when one fires](https://app.sinho.ai/alerts?do=alert&types=wyckoff%3Aeffort-vs-result&name=Effort+vs+Result)
- [Add a Scanner lane](https://app.sinho.ai/scanner?do=lane&types=wyckoff%3Aeffort-vs-result)

## How does it fire?

- **What it tells you**: Heavy participation has produced little net price change. The Signal is neutral; it does not choose an upward or downward outcome.

- **When Sinho fires**: At the candle’s close, when its volume rank is high and its absolute change from the preceding close is small enough.

## Anatomy

Three parts, in the order they happen. The line joins candle closes.

*Drawing: The past, Prior close, The close*

- **The past**
The prior candles supply the volume comparison and ATR. The line here joins candle closes.

- **Prior close**
The immediately preceding candle’s close is the reference for the current price change.

- **The close**
Heavy volume ends with no more than 0.25× ATR of net change. Sinho fires here.

## What Sinho checks

The main rules, in plain words.

- **Heavy participation**
The candle trades on unusually heavy volume.

- **Change between closes**
Sinho measures the absolute difference between the current candle’s close and the immediately preceding candle’s close.

- **Little net progress**
Despite that activity, the close makes little progress from the preceding close.

- **A neutral reading**
The Signal remains neutral whether the small net change is upward, downward or zero. It records the mismatch between activity and progress.

- **The close**
Sinho fires when a candle closes with heavy volume but little net price progress.

## Recent Effort vs Result Signals

Every Effort vs Result Sinho fires, on every exchange and timeframe, is in the Feed as it happens.

- [See live Effort vs Result Signals](https://app.sinho.ai/feed/signals?do=feed&types=wyckoff%3Aeffort-vs-result)

## Questions traders ask

### Does the candle itself have to be narrow?

No. Price can travel a wide high-to-low range and still finish near the preceding close. This rule limits net change, not the distance traveled within the candle.

### Must it be a doji?

No. A doji compares a candle’s close with its own open. This type compares the close with the preceding candle’s close.

### Does high activity prove who is absorbing the orders?

No. The measured facts are high volume and little net progress. The Signal does not identify particular buyers or sellers.

### Can several consecutive candles qualify?

Yes. Each completed candle is evaluated against its own comparison history and preceding close. This type does not require a quiet reset between fires.

### Does it create a new level?

No. It records this event without adding a new LevelBook level.

## Related

### Related Signals

[
A directional rejection

Stopping Volume

Stopping Volume adds a declining context, a lower low and an upper-half close.
](https://sinho.ai/university/signals/stopping-volume)[
Quiet participation

No Demand

No Demand looks for low volume and a narrow upward close in a flat or falling context.
](https://sinho.ai/university/signals/no-demand)

It can count toward Volume, one of the strength filters, when it supports a Setup’s direction.

## Key takeaways

- 1
Effort vs Result compares high activity with little net change.

- 2
Volume ranks at least at the 90th percentile of the prior comparison history.

- 3
The close stays within 0.25× ATR of the preceding close, regardless of the candle’s full range.

- 4
The reading is neutral and creates no new LevelBook level.

## Words on this page

- **Candle range**: The distance from a candle's low to its high, including both wicks.

- **At the close**: Sinho checks the rule when the candle closes, and fires then.

- **ATR**: Average true range: how far a bar usually travels, counting gaps between bars.

- **Percentile rank**: The share of prior candles whose volume or full range is strictly smaller. Sinho compares the current candle with its past, excluding itself.

- **Wilder ATR**: A smoothed average of true range. Sinho uses the prior candle’s value, before the candle being evaluated changes it.

Source: https://sinho.ai/university/signals/effort-vs-result
